Fixing a Fixed Mindset

This article originally appeared on Tabata Times. 

By Rachel Binette

As a coach, I see every WOD as an opportunity for my athletes. That opportunity may be physical, as in practicing skills they have not mastered or getting stronger or faster. That opportunity may also be mental, as either a test of sheer mental toughness or as part of the process of evaluating and improving an athlete’s mindset.

Mindset can be defined as a set of beliefs about oneself and others, and developing a positive mindset will make the difference between plateauing in fitness or reaching our potential. While there are many facets of mindset, in this article we will only discuss fixed and growth mindsets.

Dr. Carol Dweck, a social psychology researcher at Stanford University, discovered the growth and fixed mindsets through decades of research. She defines the fixed mindset individual as someone who believes that talent, intelligence, and other abilities are fixed traits: you either have them, or you don’t. The growth mindset individual, on the other hand, believes that their basic abilities can be developed through effort.

It is possible for us to hold a fixed mindset about some things and a growth mindset about others. We can hold fixed mindsets about what our age, body composition, skills, intelligence, and even time (weeks/months/years) spent doing CrossFit mean for us when we do a WOD. And we can hold the same fixed mindsets about others.

An athlete with a growth mindset, on the other hand, believes that they and others are a work in progress at all stages of their athletic journey. This mindset will make all the difference when we face the inevitable challenges and failures that come with CrossFit.

An athlete with a growth mindset is not afraid of failure. We could define failure as not PRing on a lift or coming in last on a WOD, but more frequently, we tend to define failure as struggling, especially with certain movements, like double unders and pull-ups. But struggling is not failure. We may fail reps and attempts along the way, but being challenged does not define us as bad athletes — it just means we are a work in progress.

It is easy to cherry-pick workouts based on avoiding skills that we struggle with. It is easy to miscount reps because we know we are falling behind. It is easy to talk ourselves into believing that there are reasons beyond effort that we haven’t improved. But because we do CrossFit, we have chosen a program that does not celebrate “easy” — we have chosen to accept and celebrate challenges.

Developing a growth mindset does not happen overnight. It takes focused practice, just like any skill we practice in CrossFit. How do we fix a fixed mindset, either in ourselves or in our athletes?

1. Notice when you or your athlete are thinking with a fixed mindset.
Are we making excuses? Do we feel discouraged every time we struggle or watch an athlete struggle? Do we avoid WODs we might struggle with?

2. Re-frame fixed mindset thoughts.
“It’s up to me to put in the work.” “It’s Ok if this is difficult. I can get better.” “This WOD will be good practice for me.”

3. Seek out feedback and implement it with all you’ve got.
Ask coaches for programming to help you get your first pull-up. Film yourself performing lifts and ask other athletes at your box for feedback.

4. Set behavior-based goals.
Instead of setting the goal of getting your first muscle-up this month or going sub 2:00 on your Fran time, figure out what training you need to perform in order to reach that larger goal. Maybe doing 5×5 pull-ups, ring dips, and/or muscle-up transitions twice a week is the way to get that muscle-up. Maybe having a coach watch our thruster technique will allow us to improve our efficiency, or maybe we need to add some engine training and remove some strength work to lower that Fran time. Whatever the larger goal, set behavior-based goals in order to reach them, and ask a coach for help!


Rachel Binette
CrossFit Level 2
American Red Cross: CPR/First Aid/AED
To book a training session with Rachel click here


Summer Youth/Teens Classes 2022

Summer Youth/Teens ClassesWe will be running a limited Summer program this year We currently have open spots for this summer session! Our Summer Session will


Fill out the form below

Learn more about how joining our community can help you reach your health and fitness goals.